Home >Unlabelled > Slam dunk the NBA slam dunk contest - ESPN
Slam dunk the NBA slam dunk contest - ESPN
Posted on Tuesday, February 21, 2012 by NBA Playoff Schedule 2012
Originally Published: February 22, 2012
It's time has come and gone, especially now that the top players won't take part
When the NBA announced that the participants are Chase Budinger, Paul George, Iman Shumpert and Derrick Williams, I thought for a second that maybe the league was staging a reunion concert of a defunct boy band.
Then I realized: Those are the guys in this weekend's slam dunk contest.
Glenn James/NBAE/Getty ImagesHere's proof that Paul George can dunk. But is he who you really want to see in the slam dunk contest?
No offense, but who are these people?
I'm being silly, of course. I know who they are. I just don't know why I should care about watching them perform in a contest that's become so irrelevant.
For years, the NBA has been trying to revive the slam dunk contest, tinkering with the rules here and there in hopes the event would regain some of the prestige it enjoyed when elite players competed in it.
That's not going to happen.
Right now, the slam dunk contest is pointless. And maybe it's time for the league to accept that it probably should be eliminated from All-Star programming altogether.
I expect many NBA fans might consider that sacrilegious, but I'm not simply over-reacting to this year's stunningly weak field (although those four, ahem, names certainly strengthen the case for elimination). It's a response to more than a decade of largely dull slam dunk competitions.
The fact the NBA changed the rules again this year is a subtle acknowledgement that the slam dunk contest is losing its appeal. The competition has been reduced to one round, and there won't be any judges this year. Fans will determine the champion by voting on NBA.com, Twitter or through text messaging.
In the past, the contest was two rounds and included a panel of judges; and fans voted for their favorites after the first round.
NBAE/Getty ImagesMaybe they should have a "legends" slam dunk contest, so Dr. J could try to reprise his from-the-free-throw-line virtuoso performance in 1976.
Here's the thing: Just throwing social media into the mix doesn't make it cool. And, no judges? What, were they afraid someone's mother would try to emulate JaVale McGee's mom and smooch Dr. J on live television?
There is only so much the NBA (and the players) can do to make the slam dunk competition interesting. And despite their efforts, the event has given us only sporadic moments of brilliance since its heyday in the 1980s.
Yes, there was Vince Carter's epic performance in 2000, which many consider the greatest slam dunk exhibition of all time. Yes, there was the Dwight Howard-Nate Robinson duel in 2009. And no, I haven't forgotten that Blake Griffin jumped over a Kia last year to win the slam dunk title -- which he's refused to defend this year.
Naturally, Griffin's presence produced a record 8.1 million viewers, with an estimated 10 million tuning in when he hurdled the Kia. But these lasting moments are an aberration, not the norm. With the collection of no-names in this year's contest, the NBA should brace itself for dismal ratings.
Admittedly, I'm spoiled. Dr. J appeared in the first slam dunk contest in 1984, sending the message that the competition was superstar-worthy and giving us arguably the most iconic dunk of all time. Michael Jordan willingly took the mantle from Dr. J and appeared in three slam dunk contests, finishing as a runner-up in 1985 and winning it outright in 1987 and 1988. Jordan's victory over Dominique Wilkins in '88 was controversial, but it was nevertheless the greatest slam dunk matchup in the competition's history. (Well, second greatest, maybe, next to the diminutive Spud Webb versus Nique in 1986.)
But the contest no longer delivers consistent star power. And in a superstar-driven league, it speaks to the unimportance of the event that players such as LeBron James don't care to appear.
Bruce Yeung/NBAE/Getty ImagesA car couldn't stop Blake Griffin last year. What's next? A semi-trailer truck?
If they think the dunk contest is irrelevant, then what's the point?
Considering the number of games they play and the physical toll on their bodies, NBA superstars can't be blamed for passing up the dunk contest. Certainly, you can look at it as an opportunity to discover new players, but the rookie-sophomore game seems like a better alternative for that.
All-Star Weekend is supposed to be a thank you to the fans, in part; but it's also a celebration of the greatest players in the league and a showcase of the best the NBA has to offer.
Sorry, but this year's field and past winners such as Gerald Green, Fred Jones, Desmond Mason and Harold Miner hardly fit that description. (And don't feel bad if you involuntarily raised your eyebrows when you read those names. Most people forget that they were dunk contest winners, too.)
Considering that NFL commissioner Roger Goodell is contemplating eliminating the Pro Bowl because it's become something of a joke, the idea of eliminating the slam dunk contest isn't that radical.
I understand the slam dunk contest is tradition. As a kid, I was in awe of the breathtaking dunks; but that was a different time. If you need a choir and an automobile to make the dunk contest compelling, then maybe it's time to re-think things.
In a world in which so many things compete for our attention, the slam dunk contest has become a no-name participant.
Jemele Hill can be reached at jemeleespn@gmail.com.
22 Feb, 2012
-
Source: http://news.google.com/news/url?sa=t&fd=R&usg=AFQjCNH_yk75cpUh4eQP914HRxYwgmmBCA&url=http://espn.go.com/espn/commentary/story/_/page/hill-120221/the-nba-slam-dunk-contest-all-star-weekend-become-irrelevant
--
Manage subscription | Powered by rssforward.com
Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(2069)
-
▼
February
(971)
- Power Rankings, Vol. IV
- Previewing WSU opponents: Loyola
- It's Halftime
- R.I.P. Dunk-Contest...ein Nachruf
- NBA All-Star Weekend Review
- Miami Heat: LeBron James no substance just talent!
- Video: All-Star Weekend
- Gerüchteküche (All-Star Edition)
- Stern pleased despite condensed NBA schedule - Was...
- NBA All-Star Game: Live updates from Amway Center ...
- NBA All-Star Game 2012: Kevin Love Representing Ti...
- 2012 NBA All-Star Game: LeBron James The Odds-On F...
- NBA All-Star Chat: Will Kobe Bryant get his 5th Al...
- 2012 NBA All-Star Game: East Roster Features LeBro...
- Sacramento, Maloofs meeting on Kings - USA TODAY
- Dwight Howard saga dominates NBA's second half - N...
- NBA All-Star Weekend 2012: All-Star Game, Three-Po...
- VIDEO: Kevin Love beats out Kevin Durant to win 3-...
- Daytona 500, Oscars, NBA All-Star Game may bump up...
- 2012 NBA All-Star Game: Knicks' Carmelo Anthony St...
- 2012 NBA All-Star Game Time, TV Schedule And More ...
- NBA commish talks about Seattle, Sacramento - KING...
- NBA All-Star Weekend: Flo Rida Performs A 'Good Fe...
- NBA Analysis: Miami Heat Midseason Review - Opposi...
- Magic Johnson's 1992 NBA All-Star appearance a def...
- NBA Standings 2012: Can The Mavericks Climb The St...
- David Stern: Adam Silver worthy successor as NBA c...
- Great expectations in NBA's second half - ESPN
- Previewing WSU opponents: Youngstown
- The 2012 NBA All-Star game, the L.A. story - Exami...
- Fake NBA All-Star gear leads to arrests in Orlando...
- NBA All-Star Saturday: No. 1 in Orlando ratings - ...
- NBA All-Star Weekend: Slam dunk contest and three-...
- NBA All-Star Game 2012: TV Info, Time, Anthem/Half...
- NBA All Star Basketball - KENS 5 TV
- NBA All-Star Game 2012: 5 All-Stars You Don't Want...
- David Stern says Adam Silver is ready - ESPN
- West All-Stars-East All-Stars Preview - ESPN
- NBA All-Star Game Rare Shootout Involving Iguodala...
- Is Dwyane Wade the Best Player in the NBA? - NESN.com
- 2012 NBA All-Star Game Time, TV Schedule And More ...
- NBA Slam Dunk Contest | 02.26.12 - News & Observer
- 2012 NBA All-Star Game Time, TV Schedule And More ...
- NBA commissioner David Stern has no sympathy for D...
- NBA's focus back on Howard - Bryan College Station...
- NBA Power Rankings 2012: Bulls And 76ers Boast Bes...
- Kyrie Irving talks about return of 'NBA Live 13' -...
- NBA Capsules: Utah's Evans wins Slam Dunk Contest ...
- NBA All-Star Game Live Blog: LeBron James, Kobe Br...
- NBA All-Star Game rosters - Columbus Dispatch
- NBA teams already looking beyond this year - San F...
- 2012 NBA All-Star Saturday Night - San Antonio Exp...
- 2012 NBA All-Star Skills Challenge: Celtics' Rajon...
- NBA All-Star Weekend: Slams, skills and shootout -...
- Heat, Thunder prepared to take NBA All-Star Game b...
- NBA All-Stars Shine In Skills Contests - KERO-TV 23
- NBA All-Star Game back in SLC? Not anytime soon, J...
- Stern: Silver worthy successor as NBA commissioner...
- Stern: Silver worthy successor as NBA commissioner...
- NBA Slam Dunk Contest 2012: All-Star Game Warmup B...
- NBA's David Stern: No deal yet on new arena for Sa...
- Kevin Durant, the NBA's unassuming superstar, reme...
- Celebrities at NBA All-Star Weekend - SI.com
- Tennis player Michael Chang has given advice to NB...
- For one night, Lakers and Clippers will work toget...
- All Star Weekend LeBron James still Don't Understand-
- Handing out NBA midseason awards: LeBron James loo...
- Phoenix Suns' Steve Nash, at NBA all-star game, do...
- Jerry Zgoda's Sunday Insider: There was one Magica...
- Lakers' Darvin Ham unenthusiastic about 2012 NBA d...
- NBA All-Star Weekend: Three Point Shootout, Slam D...
- NBA Trade Rumors: Suns Are Foolish Not to Trade St...
- Johnson: 'Linsanity' might bring change to NBA nar...
- NBA Trade Rumors: Lakers interested in trading for...
- NBA Four Quarters | All-Star edition - Kansas City...
- No one seems to notice, but the Spurs are a threat...
- NBA Slam Dunk Contest: Competition Has Long Histor...
- Previewing WSU players: Vaughn Duggins
- Women's Basketball
- Men's Basketball
- NBA All-Star Game a social media bonanza worldwide...
- Monroe 'steals' show at NBA Rising Stars (with vid...
- 2012 NBA Skills Challenge: Four PGs Compete In ......
- 2012 NBA Three-Point Contest: James Jones Seeks Re...
- NBA All-Star Weekend: Three-Point Contest Includes...
- NBA All-Star Weekend: Jeremy Lin Not Main Event Bu...
- Jeremy Lin humbled, humorous during All-Star weeke...
- NBA Rising Stars Game 2012: Kyrie Irving Showed Us...
- NBA All-Star Saturday Night 2012 Time, TV Schedule...
- NBA Debate: Why David Stern Should Shorten Season ...
- Not an All-Star, but Lin stars in Orlando - Atlant...
- NBA All-Stars showcase skills leading up to big ga...
- NBA All-Stars and more pitch in for charity - Orla...
- 2012 NBA Dunk Contest: Jeremy Evans Could Surprise...
- 2012 NBA All-Star Saturday: Schedule, TV Info And ...
- Syracuse vs UConn: Future NBA Studs to Watch in Bi...
- NBA All-Star Weekend: Rising Stars and the Celebri...
- Vic's Picks: NBA, Dwight Howard, Missouri-Kansas -...
- NBA Rumors: Suns Shouldn't Wait for Steve Nash's B...
- NBA: Lights, camera & stars - Daily News & Analysis
-
▼
February
(971)